Afro_Zen Posted January 24, 2023 Report Posted January 24, 2023 I recently completed an FRA of a two-storey, purpose built, general needs, residential block, and found the scenario detailed in the attached picture. Firestopping at the bottom of the electrical intake cupboard located on the ground floor. There are no basement levels within the building. The firestopping material has been applied within pipes / ducts that protrude through the floor of the intake cupboard. Passing up through the pipes are electrical cables and a water service pipe. The fire stopping material isn't ideal. My main query however, is whether fire stopping is actually required. My thinking is that fire stopping material had been applied to possibly stop a potential surge of electricity from a nearby sub station. However, considering the high voltages coming from a substation into a property, the fire stopping material currently in situ wouldn't be adequate. In additon, the fire stopping at the bottom of the water service pipework doesn't make sense either. My other thought was that the fire stopping had been applied simply to close off any potential routes of entry for rodents. Any thoughts on the matter would be much appreciated. Quote
green-foam Posted January 25, 2023 Report Posted January 25, 2023 21 hours ago, Afro_Zen said: My thinking is that fire stopping material had been applied to possibly stop a potential surge of electricity from a nearby sub station. However, considering the high voltages coming from a substation into a property, the fire stopping material currently in situ wouldn't be adequate Could you please explain your thinking behind that? How is any fire stop material going to stop an electrical surge through a cable? Quote
Afro_Zen Posted January 25, 2023 Author Report Posted January 25, 2023 Hi Green Foam, Thanks for your reply. "I don't know", is my answer, that's why I'm asking. As I stated clearly in my post, I'm uncertain of the reasoning for the fire stopping material in the floor of the electrical intake, hence the purpose of my post. As you may have also noted, I provided a couple of ideas as to why I think the fire stop may have been applied. I might be off with my line of thought, but that's the reason why I'm asking the forum. I'm just looking for some constructive feedback. Quote
AnthonyB Posted January 25, 2023 Report Posted January 25, 2023 Not a location needing stopping - probably used whatever foam they had to hand for insulation/damp/acoustic sealing Quote
Lyledunn Posted January 29, 2023 Report Posted January 29, 2023 Perhaps a water ingress measure or the like as AB suggests above. Sometimes the ducts are run from a higher level than the property. Installers would attempt all sorts of counter measures that don’t necessarily fit with common sense! What is the material used? Quote
Afro_Zen Posted January 30, 2023 Author Report Posted January 30, 2023 Thanks Anthony B, and Lyledunn. Appreciate the input from you both. This pretty much accords with the view I held that the material used was not for fire stopping purposes. @Lyledunn- Not too sure what the material is. Looks like bog standard PU foam. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.