Mike North

If there is a stay put policy, how do you get to the assembly point? If it’s a residential building, how are you going to take a roll call when you don’t know who the occupants are, if they are on holiday, have they visitors or have gone out. The fire brigade will have to do a sweep of the building to ensure that it is empty.

No external exit doors do not need strips

Occupancy numbers, 4 staff, 4 researchers. Unfortunately they hold infrequent lectures in the building with up to 50 visitors and an annual open day It has a vaulted ceiling approximately 10m with 2 detectors in the roof space It has a L2 alarm/detection with manual call points at all exits

I am looking at a historic library, the regulator has got involved. The main issue is that currently on the first floor there is a viewing gallery to the main within the room. The gallery has a single opening (no door) giving a single direction travel distance of 20m there is a further distance of 5m to the head of the stair. Off the stair are two offices, both doors will have to be replaced by replica doors. Looking at the regulations A single door cannot be installed in this position as if it swings into room there is a risk if the door tipping someone over the gallery or due to the curvature of the wall, if the door swings the other there is no clearway through. I cannot use small premises as the travel distance is excessive, the same with a single escape stair. Does anyone have any other options that I may have missed, bar putting in an additional stair or closing the building?

If it is a single portacabin, usually not

There is a legal requirement for fire stopping. Have you checked the other side of the wall? Is the wall a fire wall? The design detail should tell you what needs to be done

The height is irrelevant to fire door inspections, ALL fire doors should be inspected by a competent person a minimum of every six months and maintenance carried out on all defects. Fire Safety (England) Regulations 2022: fire door guidance (accessible) - GOV.UK (www.gov.uk) As for the different interpretations of the doors, it is a lot less work for the inspector to say that the door must be changed than listing the deficiencies and the required remedials to bring the door back to compliance. Unless there is a chain of custody, the history of the door is time consuming and difficult to track down, you pays your money and you takes your choice.

All depends on block, if there are 2 means of escape and the flat is on the top floor then probably not

A lift is sat in a shaft that connects 2 or more floors, why would you not protect it?

You could always form a new opening between the yard and kitchen which would probably need not be a fire door

I must agree, door D2 will be beaten black and blue with deliveries been transported through it. I would also suggest that D2 and the external door to the yard will also be propped open to allow cross ventilation of the kitchen. Have you thought about a free swing closer which may cure the issue

is it triple glazed? VELFAC Product Database | Windows and doors

How old are the doors? they may not need strips if the door stops are 25mm. (but they will be old doors)

Can't you claim the screed as protection

You ned to know what is happening at the junction between the concrete and the steel beams, is there a path for fire and smoke to traverse the floor/celling. Is the steel frame protected? It looks like there are some major repairs to complete, and what is there concrete (is it RAAC)

wouldn't the spare key unlock the door?

Annie BS 9999 recommends that a fire door inspection should be conducted every 6 months by a competent person

I have never seen installation instructions that specify the location of the fixings to be behind the rebated seals (indeed it could be argued that this is a weak point) instead the instructions usually state the maximum centre and the penetration depth along with the sealing techniques that can be used. Are the screw heads below the top of the frame, would filling and decoration cover them?

Look at the construction, are they solid doors, are they heavy, have they got smoke seals, is there any markings on the door. Does the cupboard run between floors or not

If the MAG lock is fire rated, pit the lock back and leave it unlocked

I don’t think that the gaps are in official government legislation, it is usually in the door certification and the installation instructions.

Simple answer, Yes you need a fire risk assessment. The responsible person would be who ever has control of the premises

A small separate brick gas meter enclosure (as long as its 1.8m from any other building) should not need to be fire rated.

Why would a developer remediate a door that was to the regulations at the time of installation if the has been altered by a third party at a later date?